1. Entertainment

We Need To Talk About Kevin

About.com Rating 3.5 Star Rating
Be the first to write a review

From

We Need To Talk About KevinOscilloscope Pictures

As a film snob, I have a tendency to get excited about a project depending on who the director is. (Okay, and sometimes the writer.) Rarely the actor, though, because, and no offense to them and the billion dollar industry in place to monitor their every breath, they are just one element of a filmmaker's overall game plan. There are a few, though, with such sharp tastes and a seeming disinterest in popularity contests that I'll see anything they do without hesitation. Tilda Swinton (Julia, I Am Love) is one of these actors.

The former model, young Communist, descendant of Scottish royalty and friend of some of Britain's most outstanding friends of Dorothy has (in addition to one hell of a wikipedia page) a remarkable nose for picking projects that are both challenging and entertaining. I say we're just a few years away before “that's such a Tilda Swinton film” enters the lexicon.

This newest one is We Need To Talk About Kevin, the story of an independent woman's life being torn apart by motherhood. It begins with a fussy baby and ends with a teen committing mass murder in a school. It is being hailed by some as a thoughtful horror film. If it ever hits the mainstream it will be examined as a serious drama. It's both, to be sure, but I'll let you in on a secret: it is also very funny.

How can you not laugh at the absurdity of a renown, world-traveler and author locking horns with an eight year old boy who purposely shits his pants just to annoy his mother? How can you not laugh when a baby just cries and cries and cries so mom pushes the stroller closer to a jackhammer to get some relief? How can you not laugh when a clueless Dad buys this young terror WEAPONS as a gift?

Kevin is one long game of stakes-raising, watching this horrible boy turn into an even more horrible man. Our sympathies (mine, at least) are wholly with Swinton even if, by some Middle American standards, she is less than an ideal Mom. (How dare she have aspirations outside the home! Stone her!)

One of the few unbreakable taboos in our culture is the strength of a mother and child's love. Well, some people are just rotten. Do they stop being rotten because they have a mom? Or, for that matter, a son?

There are theories out there that We Need To Talk About Kevin is told from the perspective of an unreliable narrator. (It is all through Swinton's flashbacks.) I say, this is a theory floated by the weak! Why do we refuse to admit that there are assholes in the world and that they are born that way?

We Need To Talk About Kevin comes to us from Scottish director Lynne Ramsay, a not-very-prolific filmmaker whose two prior works seem an appropriate build-up to this piece. The first, Ratcatcher was a gross and gritty tale about poverty in a British housing project. Morvern Callar was a hallucinatory ride through Spain with a morally blank plagiarist that was shot as though it were a travelogue from outer space.

Kevin is not quite so experimental, but it makes terrific use of empty spaces in the grotesque suburban McMansion. Ramsay loves montage, as well as floating around in slow moving cars as the least expected song plays on the soundtrack. (When we aren't hearing Buddy Holly or the Beach Boys, its an original score by Johnny Greenwood.)

The overall vibe is one that says, yes, let's take this all seriously, but let's also have a devilishly good time with this, too. Am I going to hell for saying I “enjoyed” a movie that features a Columbine-esque massacre as its climax? Don't blame me, blame Swinton and Ramsay.

©2012 About.com. All rights reserved.

A part of The New York Times Company.